April 2012
March 2012
This is from this really interesting articlethat explains how a lot of your top 40 radio hit sausage is made. There’s also this: “Around Roc the Mic, writing songs for any reason other than making hits is a waste of time.”
Now, my question to any pop-friendly, anti-rockist music writers on here would be how is this any better, or conceptually different from, like, SEO or link aggregator sites like HuffPo or Buzzfeed?
Or, conversely, explain to me why SEO or aggregator sites are really cool and make the Internet a totally better place.
(via erikonymous)
I’d say the easy answer is that a song (particularly the non-lyrical parts) is not a blog post. Blog posts are made out of words instead of chord progressions, melodies, and harmonies. It’s a bit different than trying to find a way to work Christina Hendricks boobs into your post, because copy/paste can have far more expensive results when you’re talking about a song. You could get a computer to do SEO, but hooks are different animals. Also, songwriting is a skill, not necessarily an outcome of inspiration. Like drawing or sculpture, it can be practiced and improved. So I don’t see what’s wrong with trying to write a hit. It’s no stranger a goal than write a hortatory essay, paint a landscape.
(via lastbutnotleast)
For the record (yuk, yuk), I don’t think there’s anything intrinsically wrong with trying to write a hit. Hell, I write music myself, and I’d really like for one of my songs to make me a lot of money someday. But I feel that the context matters, particularly here. Music is an art form, sure. But songwriting can rightly be considered a craft, a skill that can be acquired and honed. I would argue that writing a super SEO-baity headline or article is every bit a skill, one which can get you hired or fired in our current marketplace. Furthermore, music theory (with which I’ll be the first to admit only a passing familiarity) shows that people interpret that very mess of chord progressions, melodies, and harmonies not only instinctively, but consistently. Major chords and keys make us feel happy, even triumphant. Minor keys make us dolorous, introspective. There are very few pop hits written in minor keys! It goes even further, such that we instinctively associate certain keys with occidental/oriental cultural traditions. Music is inarguably an art, but some songwriters have it down to a science.
(via erikonymous)
This is from this really interesting articlethat explains how a lot of your top 40 radio hit sausage is made. There’s also this: “Around Roc the Mic, writing songs for any reason other than making hits is a waste of time.”
Now, my question to any pop-friendly, anti-rockist music writers on here would be how is this any better, or conceptually different from, like, SEO or link aggregator sites like HuffPo or Buzzfeed?
Or, conversely, explain to me why SEO or aggregator sites are really cool and make the Internet a totally better place.
(via erikonymous)
I’d say the easy answer is that a song (particularly the non-lyrical parts) is not a blog post. Blog posts are made out of words instead of chord progressions, melodies, and harmonies. It’s a bit different than trying to find a way to work Christina Hendricks boobs into your post, because copy/paste can have far more expensive results when you’re talking about a song. You could get a computer to do SEO, but hooks are different animals. Also, songwriting is a skill, not necessarily an outcome of inspiration. Like drawing or sculpture, it can be practiced and improved. So I don’t see what’s wrong with trying to write a hit. It’s no stranger a goal than write a hortatory essay, paint a landscape.
(via lastbutnotleast)
For the record (yuk, yuk), I don’t think there’s anything intrinsically wrong with trying to write a hit. Hell, I write music myself, and I’d really like for one of my songs to make me a lot of money someday. But I feel that the context matters, particularly here. Music is an art form, sure. But songwriting can rightly be considered a craft, a skill that can be acquired and honed. I would argue that writing a super SEO-baity headline or article is every bit a skill, one which can get you hired or fired in our current marketplace. Furthermore, music theory (with which I’ll be the first to admit only a passing familiarity) shows that people interpret that very mess of chord progressions, melodies, and harmonies not only instinctively, but consistently. Major chords and keys make us feel happy, even triumphant. Minor keys make us dolorous, introspective. There are very few pop hits written in minor keys! It goes even further, such that we instinctively associate certain keys with occidental/oriental cultural traditions. Music is inarguably an art, but some songwriters have it down to a science.
(via erikonymous)
Dude, really? No hits in minor keys?
Rolling in the Deep
House of the Rising Sun
Eleanor Rigby
Stairway to Heaven
Losing My Religion
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Smells Like Teen Spirit
Space Oddity
It’s a Man’s Man’s Man’s World
Never Gonna Give You Up
Stayin’ Alive
Livin’ La Vida Loca
This is Hardcore
Fallin’
Billie Jean
All Along the Watchtower
…Baby One More Time
Hello
Bridge Over Troubled Water
(I’m Not Your) Stepping Stone
It’s Now Or Never
Stan
Another One Bites the Dust
Money Money Money
Like a Prayer
and many more!